If you are arrested for Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol (OUI), you will be asked to consent to a chemical test to determine your Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC). Massachusetts is an implied consent state. This means that if you are arrested for OUI, you are deemed to have consented to a breathalyzer test. So, if you refuse to take the breath test, there is an administrative penalty in the form of a driver’s license suspension.
Bear in mind that after pulling a driver over and suspecting alcohol intoxication or impairment, the police will often ask the driver to take a breath test on the side of the road. This preliminary breath test (PBT) is not admissible in court, but rather is used by the police to help them make the probable cause determination of whether or not to arrest and charge the driver with OUI.
For example, if the police detect an odor of alcohol on a driver’s breath, and then the driver exhibits some difficulty performing field sobriety tests, the officer may offer the driver a PBT. If the PBT reading is, for example, a .06, then the officer may conclude that the driver is not under the influence of alcohol and decide not to make the arrest. For this reason, it is generally a good idea to take the PBT if it is offered, so long as you think there is a chance that your result will be below the legal limit of .08. However, there is no penalty for refusing to take a PBT.
If you are arrested for OUI, the police will offer you a breath test (breathalyzer) at the police station. The results of this breath test are admissible in court. For of-age drivers (21 years or older), the RMV will impose an immediate 30-day administrative driver’s license suspension for a failed breath test. After 30 days, the driver can apply for a license reinstatement with the RMV. Typically, the fee for license reinstatement is approximately $500.00, and the driver must make an appointment with an RMV hearings officer. At present, it usually takes several weeks or months to get an appointment with a hearings officer.
If a person arrested for OUI refuses to take the breath test at the police station, then the RMV will immediately administratively suspend his or her driver’s license for at least 180 days, depending on how many prior OUI offenses are on the individual’s criminal record. Additional suspension periods are imposed for drivers under age 21.
For drivers over the age of 21
Number of Prior OUIs Suspension Period
None 180 days
One 3 years
Two 5 years
Three or more Lifetime
If your driver’s license is suspended for a breathalyzer refusal and you are later found not guilty of the OUI charge, then you can petition the court to reinstate your license at the conclusion of the trial. There is a presumption that the license should be restored after an acquittal, but the prosecutor can overcome this presumption upon a showing that your further operation of a motor vehicle would endanger the safety of the public.
As in the case with a suspension for breath test failure, the individual must see an RMV hearings officer to reinstate a driver’s license after a judge orders the license reinstated following an acquittal, or at the conclusion of the suspension period for breath test refusal.
There is also a procedure for appealing a license suspension for refusing a breath test, but the standard for overturning this suspension is difficult to meet, and the deadline to do so – 15 days from the date of the breath test refusal, makes it even more difficult to take advantage of. This is not helped by the fact that such a hearing can only be held in Boston.
On the rare occasion that a driver gets a hearing in Boston on the issue of a breath test refusal license suspension, the only arguments that the RMV will hear are the following, namely:
- the police officer did not have reasonable grounds to arrest you for OUI;
- you were not arrested; or
- you did not refuse the breathalyzer test.
The most common of these arguments in my experience is that the driver did not actually refuse to take the breath test. This is because the police sometimes stop the test when they suspect that the person is intentionally not blowing hard enough into the breathalyzer machine in an attempt to “fool” the device. If the driver has, for example, a respiratory issue that makes it impossible to take the breath test, that might be a winning argument.
If an individual is convicted of operating under the influence (or admits to sufficient facts for a finding of guilty and is sentenced to complete a driver alcohol program as a condition of probation), there is separate driver’s license suspension. This is not an administrative penalty, but rather a criminal sanction.
A license suspension imposed after an OUI conviction is added onto any remaining period of license suspension for refusing the breath test.
As is the case with license suspensions for breath test refusal, the length of any suspension for a conviction or admission to OUI varies depending on how many prior OUI convictions/admissions the individual has had. Out-of-state prior OUIs are included in the calculation.
21 and Older Operating Under the Influence of Alcohol (or Drugs) License Suspension
1st Offense One year suspension (unless sentenced to the driver alcohol program)
2nd Offense Two-year suspension
3rd Offense Eight-year suspension
4th Offense Ten-year suspension
5th Offense Lifetime suspension
For a 1st offense only, a defendant can typically admit to the OUI and avoid a conviction and the one-year suspension, provided that he or she agrees to attend an approved outpatient driver alcohol education program. The license suspension in this event is 45-90 days, but usually 45 days.
For any OUI conviction beyond a 1st offense, there is a requirement that the driver only operate a motor vehicle that has an ignition interlock device installed. This device requires the driver to blow into a tube to measure his or her breath alcohol before starting the vehicle.
Hardship Licenses
Once one-half of the license suspension for an OUI conviction or admission has elapsed, the driver can apply for a hearing before an RMV hearings officer to obtain a hardship license, sometimes referred to as a “Cinderella license.” Hardship licenses typically allow operation of a vehicle for a 12-hour period, so that a person can commute to and from work. The hearings officer will only issue a hardship license upon a showing of a “hardship.” In order to make such a showing, at a minimum, the driver will need to produce proof of employment on the employer’s letterhead, along with information regarding the lack of alternative transportation available to the driver.
For 1st offenders only, the RMV will entertain a hardship application before the expiration of one-half of the license suspension period, so long as 3 days have passed since the court case was resolved, and the driver has registered for the driver alcohol education program.
Attorney Kevin D. Quinlan
Uxbridge, Worcester County, Massachusetts